As soon as Josh Gasser’s desperation heave missed the mark
Thursday night, ending Wisconsin’s season, I knew the Bo Ryan critics would be
back out in full force. Yes, despite the fact that the Badgers have just made
the Sweet 16 two years in a row for the first time in program history, there is
a vocal minority out there calling for the UW head coach to be replaced.
The head coach who became the winningest coach in Wisconsin
history with the Badgers’ Big Ten tournament win over Indiana.
The head coach who has never finished outside the top four
in the Big Ten in eleven years at the helm in Madison.
It would be one thing if these numbers had taken a hit, but
these critics aren’t coming out after a disappointing season. Though many
Badger fans are unable to get beyond the four home losses and the “early” NCAA
Tournament exit, the 2011-2012 season was one of the more remarkable campaigns
in the 100-plus years that basketball has been played at UW.
In fact, I would argue that Bo Ryan had his best season as a
coach, taking a team that lost two of its top three scorers and still managing
to win 26 games, the third most the program has ever recorded in a single
season.
The reason that the critics are out there is clear: Bo Ryan
has never reached a Final Four. While a national title is the ultimate goal for
every team every season, very few coaches are able to turn the dream into a
reality.
Hall of Fame coaches like Gene Keady (Purdue) and John
Cheney (Temple) never reached the promise land.
In 37 years at Syracuse, Jim Boeheim has only been to the
Final Four three times, winning just one national title. And having a roster
filled with future NBA stars certainly helps that cause.
Even John Wooden, considered the greatest coach in college
basketball history, spent two years at Indiana State and another 13 at UCLA
before making his first run to the Final Four.
Even fewer are able to do so at a school like Wisconsin.
Madison is a great place to go to school: we all know that.
But when it comes to recruiting the big names in high school basketball, the
tranquility of the Terrace on that infrequent sunny day cant compete with the
glitz and glamor of Westwood, the hoops hysteria of Duke and UNC, or the
tradition of Phog Allen Fieldhouse and Kansas.
After suddenly becoming one of the preeminent programs in
the college basketball world, the Badgers certainly are worthy of the high
expectations that fans have begun to levy upon them. But while it would be nice
to think that Wisconsin could simply get top talent and start playing a style
of basketball conducive to regular Final Four trips, that simply isn’t
reflective of the reality in which Bo Ryan and his staff have built a top-notch
program that gets just about everything it can out of the circumstances.
As someone who used to be a student at a “powerhouse”
basketball school, I can tell you that the grass certainly isn’t greener.
At Wisconsin we have a basketball team that works hard,
plays hard, and does things the right way. Oh, and they haven’t done too poorly
on the court either.
On the other hand, the big name schools also have big name
issues. Top talent comes with big time egos, egos that someone result in a
bending of the rules and almost always result in a tenuous battle between
national title contention and sudden mediocrity.
Personally, having seen both sides of the proverbial coin, I
would choose Wisconsin every time. I would much rather have a team that I can
count on being in the NCAA Tournament year in and year out, not to mention
doing so within the rules (as far as I can tell).
Since Bo Ryan took over as head coach, no program has had as
many years with an NCAA Tournament win (10) as Wisconsin. No one.
Yes, it would be nice to finally get over the hump and make
a run to the Final Four. And yes, it hurts to see the Badgers come oh so close
and fall short once again.
But don’t lose perspective. What coach Ryan has built at UW
is something truly special, something that all of us should be proud to be even
the slightest part of. Now is certainly not the time to throw all of that away.